Skip to content
AFX Research logo

· AFX Research

Unlawful Restrictive Covenants and How They Come Off a Title

What the recorded covenant still says, why it is unenforceable, and the statutory process most states now provide for removing it.

A recorded subdivision declaration open on a desk beside a county index volume, the kind of document a chain of title search returns
Table of Contents

Pull a full chain on almost any subdivision platted between the 1920s and the late 1940s and you will eventually read a paragraph nobody wants to read aloud. A covenant restricting ownership or occupancy by race, religion or national origin, recorded in the declaration, repeated in the deeds, and still sitting in the county index today. It has been unenforceable for the better part of eighty years. It is also still in the record, and clients ask what to do about it.

That question now has a statutory answer in most states, and it is a question of recorded documents rather than of litigation. What follows is how the provision got there, why it survives in the index, and the process a chain of title search supports when somebody wants it gone.

Why it is still in the record

Shelley v. Kraemer held in 1948 that a court cannot enforce a racially restrictive covenant, and the Fair Housing Act of 1968 made it unlawful to write or enforce one. Neither did anything to the paper. A recorded instrument stays recorded, because the whole point of a land records system is that it preserves what was filed rather than what is currently lawful.

So the covenant sits in two places. It sits in the original declaration or plat, which is a document the county will not alter. And it frequently sits in the deeds themselves, because mid century conveyancers copied the restrictions forward deed after deed, which is why the language turns up in instruments recorded long after it stopped meaning anything.

A searcher reports it because it is there. That is not an endorsement and it is not a title exception in the ordinary sense — the provision is void and no examiner treats it as a cloud on marketability. It is a finding, and the finding is what starts the removal process.

The seven steps a removal takes

Most states that have adopted a statute follow a broadly similar shape. The details differ considerably, so the sequence below is a map rather than a form to follow.

1. Identify the exact instrument

The removal is directed at a specific recorded document, so the search has to produce the book and page, the recording date and the precise text of the provision. A paraphrase will not do. This is ordinary chain of title work.

2. Establish who may file

Statutes vary on standing. Many allow any owner of property subject to the covenant to act alone. Some allow an association to act for the whole subdivision, and a few permit a title company or a state agency to file.

3. Prepare the statutory form

Most states prescribe a form, frequently called a restrictive covenant modification, an affidavit, or a notice of unlawful restriction. It identifies the original instrument, quotes or attaches the offending language, and states that the provision is void.

4. Submit it for review where required

Several states route the document through a county attorney, a registrar or a court for a short review before recording. The review confirms the provision is of the type the statute reaches, and it is usually brief and procedural.

5. Record it against the property

The approved document is recorded and indexed, which is what makes it findable by the next searcher. In some states it attaches to the single parcel, in others it operates on the whole subdivision.

6. Check what the recorder does with the original

Practice differs sharply here. Some offices strike the language from the public image, some annotate the original with a marginal reference, and some leave the original untouched and rely entirely on the new filing.

The final step is the one people skip. Run the parcel again and confirm the modification is indexed where a searcher will find it, because an instrument that was recorded but indexed badly has not done its job.

A county recorder index terminal showing recorded instruments against a parcel, used to confirm that a restrictive covenant modification was indexed correctly

What this changes, and what it does not

It does not change enforceability, because the provision was already void. Nothing recorded today makes it any more void than it was in 1968.

What it changes is the reading experience. The next buyer, the next lender and the next searcher see a recorded instrument saying plainly that the language has no effect, instead of a bare covenant with no commentary attached. For many clients that is the entire point, and it is a reasonable one.

It also does not touch the rest of the declaration. Setbacks, use restrictions, architectural controls and the covenants that are still enforceable survive untouched, which is why the statutory form is narrow and targeted rather than a wholesale cancellation. A client who wants the whole declaration terminated is asking a different and much harder question, usually answered under the association’s own amendment provisions or by a quiet title action.

Where the practical risk sits

Three places, in our experience.

  • Missing the provision entirely. A current owner search will not reach a 1931 declaration. Only a chain search of sufficient depth returns it, which is the same depth point raised by recording acts and priority.
  • Quoting it loosely. The statutory form identifies specific language in a specific instrument, and an inaccurate quotation can send the filing back.
  • Assuming the original was altered. If the office leaves the original image intact, a searcher who reads only the declaration still sees the covenant. The modification has to be found as well, which argues for a search that returns the complete recorded file rather than a summary.

An attorney reviewing a stack of recorded deeds and a subdivision declaration, checking which instruments carried a restriction forward

How AFX Research helps

We run in-person searches, certified abstracts and full document copies from any U.S. county, delivered in 12 to 72 hours and backed by our search guarantee. For this work that means the declaration and the plat as recorded, every deed in the chain that carried the language forward, the book and page for each, and the complete recorded image rather than an index abstract. Recording and indexing practice varies county by county, and a search reports what was found of record rather than everything that exists.

Order a title search on the parcel, or compare our search products if you are scoping a subdivision wide project rather than a single lot.

Start Your Title Search Today

Fast, accurate property title research, nationwide. Order online in minutes, or talk to our team about the search that fits your matter.

Questions? Call 877-848-5337 ext. 138 or send us a message