Skip to content
AFX Research logo

· AFX Research

Color of Title and Tax Payment Statutes in Title Research

How short-form adverse possession works, what color of title requires, and why a defective deed plus paid tax receipts can cut a possession period in half.

A dark timber cabin lit from within at dusk, standing among autumn trees behind a wooden deck strung with lights
Table of Contents

Most practitioners know the long version of adverse possession — fifteen or twenty years of open, notorious, hostile, continuous possession. Far fewer think immediately of the short version, which in a great many states runs seven years or even five, and which turns on two things a records search can actually find, a recorded instrument that looks like a deed and a receipt showing somebody paid the taxes. When both are present, the clock the record implies may be much shorter than the one you assumed.

This is one of the places where a records search earns its fee, because the elements of the short statute are documentary in a way the common-law elements never are.

What “color of title” actually means

Color of title is a written instrument that appears to convey title and does not. It is the written claim, not the quality of it. The classic examples are familiar once you start looking for them.

  • A deed from a grantor who never owned the land, or owned only part of it.
  • A tax deed that failed for a notice defect.
  • A deed with a legal description that describes more than the grantor held.
  • A deed from one of several co-tenants purporting to convey the whole.
  • A deed executed by someone without authority, such as an officer of a dissolved entity.

What matters is that the instrument is facially a conveyance. A contract to purchase is usually not color of title. An unrecorded scrap of paper usually is not either, in the states that require recording. A wild deed, on the other hand, often is exactly that — an instrument sitting outside the chain, recorded, describing the parcel, signed by a stranger to title.

The practical consequence is the one clients miss. Color of title is not a defect to be cleared. In the hands of a possessor, it is an asset, because it shortens the statutory period and because in most states it extends the claim to the whole of the land described rather than only the part actually occupied.

A newly built white rendered house standing on bare graded ground, with survey stakes and a pallet of blocks in the unfinished front yard

Why tax payment is the other half

A large group of states pair color of title with payment of taxes, and the pairing is deliberate. Taxes paid under a recorded instrument produce an annual public record that the true owner could have seen, which is what makes the shortened period defensible.

The statutes vary more than any summary can capture, but a few patterns recur.

  • Color of title plus taxes for a short term. Five to seven years is typical.
  • Color of title alone, slightly longer. Ten years in several states.
  • Possession without color, full term. Fifteen to twenty-one years, and limited to the ground actually held.
  • Taxes alone, no possession. Almost never sufficient by itself, though it strengthens everything else.

The research question that follows is narrow and answerable. Who has been paying, under what instrument, and for how long?

The seven checks that matter

1. Find the instrument

Run the chain and pull every deed touching the parcel, including the ones that do not connect. An instrument that breaks the chain is the one most likely to be functioning as color of title.

2. Read the description against the deed in the chain

Overlap is the point. Compare the description in the stray instrument to the description in the record owner’s deed, and mark the area claimed by both.

3. Check whether it was recorded, and when

In most color-of-title states the recording date starts the clock. The date on the instrument is not the date that matters.

4. Pull the tax history

Get the assessment and payment history for the full statutory period, not for the last three years. Gaps matter, and a single missed year resets the count in some jurisdictions.

5. Identify who paid

A payment made by a mortgage servicer out of escrow is paid on the record owner’s behalf, not the possessor’s. Trace the payer, not just the payment.

6. Look for acknowledgment of the true owner

A recorded lease, an offer to purchase or a permission letter can defeat hostility entirely. These turn up in the record more often than people expect.

7. Check what has already been filed about it

A prior quiet title action, a lis pendens, or a recorded agreement may have settled the question already, or may show the dispute is live.

Two women walking and talking on a sidewalk beside a red brick building with louvred vents, trees overhead

Where it interacts with other doctrines

Color of title does not operate alone. A marketable record title act can extinguish the very interest a possessor is adverse to, which sometimes makes the adverse possession argument unnecessary. A failed tax deed sale is one of the most common sources of color of title in the country, because a purchaser who took a defective tax deed and then paid taxes for seven years has assembled both elements without ever intending to.

And where the dispute is a strip rather than a parcel, boundary by acquiescence frequently reaches the same result on different facts, with no instrument required at all.

A search establishes what is recorded and what the tax records show. Whether the statutory elements are satisfied, and whether possession was in fact hostile and continuous, are questions of fact and law for counsel. Recording and assessment practice varies by county, and an empty result is evidence that nothing was found of record over the term searched rather than proof that no claim exists.

What AFX Research can do about it

Our certified abstractors run in-person searches, produce certified abstracts, and pull full document copies from any U.S. county, delivered in 12 to 72 hours and backed by our search guarantee. On a color-of-title question that means the full chain, the off-chain instruments, and the tax payment history as one package rather than three separate orders. Firms doing this work regularly can see the range on our property attorneys page.

Order a title search for the parcel, or compare our search products if you are not yet sure which term the question needs.

Start Your Title Search Today

Fast, accurate property title research, nationwide. Order online in minutes, or talk to our team about the search that fits your matter.

Questions? Call 877-848-5337 ext. 138 or send us a message